The Quick Guide to Prediabetes SOAP Note

Prediabetes sits in a frustrating gray zone of medical practice.

Your patient's numbers aren't quite bad enough for diabetes medication, but they're too high to ignore.

You know that intervening now could prevent or delay diabetes entirely, but getting insurance to cover diabetes prevention programs or nutrition counseling often feels impossible.

The documentation becomes the bottleneck.

Insurance companies want specific diagnostic codes, proof of eligibility criteria, and evidence of medical necessity before approving prevention services that could save them thousands in future diabetes costs.

Many providers don't realize that prediabetes documentation requires different language than diabetes documentation—and that subtle wording changes can mean the difference between approved and denied coverage for prevention programs.

I built SOAP Notes Doctor to handle these documentation nuances automatically, turning your clinical assessment into notes that unlock access to prevention resources your patients desperately need.

Let me show you exactly what prediabetes documentation needs to accomplish.

Why Prediabetes Documentation Matters More Than You Think

Most chronic conditions get diagnosed, treated, and monitored through a predictable documentation pattern.

Prediabetes is different because the entire goal is intervention before disease develops.

Your documentation needs to accomplish something unusual: justify intensive intervention for a condition that technically isn't a disease yet.

Here's what makes prediabetes documentation strategically important:

CDC-recognized Diabetes Prevention Programs require specific documentation proving prediabetes diagnosis and BMI criteria for insurance coverage.

Preventive nutrition counseling (often covered at 100% under ACA) needs proper diagnosis codes and medical necessity documentation.

Medications like metformin for diabetes prevention require documented evidence of high risk and failed lifestyle modification attempts.

Future diabetes claims may be scrutinized if there's no documentation trail showing prediabetes was identified and addressed.

Your prediabetes notes create a paper trail that can unlock thousands of dollars in preventive services while protecting you from future questions about why diabetes wasn't prevented.

The Insurance Coverage Puzzle for Prediabetes

Understanding what insurance will and won't cover for prediabetes helps you document strategically.

Most insurance plans cover:

• Annual screening labs (HbA1c, fasting glucose) as preventive care
• Diabetes Prevention Programs (DPP) when properly documented
• Medical nutrition therapy in some cases
• Preventive counseling visits

But coverage gets denied when:

• Documentation doesn't include specific diagnostic criteria (actual HbA1c or glucose values)
• BMI isn't documented for DPP referrals (programs require BMI ≥25, or ≥23 for Asian Americans)
• Notes don't establish medical necessity for counseling
• Providers use vague language like "borderline diabetes" instead of proper diagnostic terminology

Your documentation needs to check very specific boxes to trigger coverage approval.

Example 1: New Prediabetes Diagnosis, Prevention Program Referral

Patient: 48-year-old Hispanic female
Chief Complaint: Routine physical, reviewing lab results
Visit: Annual wellness exam follow-up

S – Subjective:

Patient returns to discuss lab results from annual physical. Reports feeling well overall with good energy. No polyuria, polydipsia, or unexplained weight changes. Family history significant for type 2 diabetes in mother (diagnosed age 52) and maternal grandmother. Works as administrative assistant, describes sedentary job. Reports eating out frequently for lunch, typically fast food or restaurant meals. Snacks on chips and sweets throughout workday. No regular exercise routine, occasionally walks on weekends. Never smoked. Concerned about family history of diabetes and willing to make lifestyle changes to avoid "ending up like my mother."

O – Objective:

Vital Signs: BP 128/82, HR 76, Wt 178 lbs, Ht 5'4", BMI 30.5
General: Overweight Hispanic female, no acute distress
Labs (fasting, drawn 1 week ago):

• HbA1c: 6.1% (prediabetes range 5.7-6.4%)
• Fasting glucose: 112 mg/dL (prediabetes range 100-125 mg/dL)
• Lipid panel: Total cholesterol 198, LDL 118, HDL 48, Triglycerides 160
• Creatinine: 0.9 mg/dL (eGFR >60)
• ALT: 34 U/L (normal)

A – Assessment:

Prediabetes (ICD-10: R73.03), confirmed by HbA1c 6.1% and fasting glucose 112 mg/dL meeting American Diabetes Association diagnostic criteria. Patient at high risk for progression to type 2 diabetes based on multiple risk factors: obesity (BMI 30.5), Hispanic ethnicity, strong family history, sedentary lifestyle, and poor dietary habits. Without intervention, estimated 70% chance of developing type 2 diabetes within 10 years. Excellent candidate for intensive lifestyle intervention through diabetes prevention program. Also noted: overweight/obesity (ICD-10: E66.9), dyslipidemia with borderline-high triglycerides, family history of diabetes (ICD-10: Z83.3).

P – Plan:

Diabetes Prevention Program Referral: Referred patient to CDC-recognized Diabetes Prevention Program through [local program name]. Program provides year-long intensive lifestyle intervention with goal of 5-7% weight loss and 150 minutes weekly physical activity. Submitted referral documentation including prediabetes diagnosis (HbA1c 6.1%, FBG 112), BMI 30.5, and insurance information for coverage determination. Explained that program is often fully covered by insurance and has been proven to reduce diabetes risk by 58%.

Lifestyle Counseling: Discussed specific dietary modifications focusing on reducing refined carbohydrates and added sugars, increasing fiber intake, and portion control. Provided handout on plate method for balanced meals. Recommended food diary to increase awareness of eating patterns. Encouraged starting with achievable exercise goal of 20-30 minute walks 5 days weekly, gradually building to 150 minutes weekly.

Weight Loss Goal: Target initial weight loss of 10-12 lbs (5-7% of current body weight) over next 6 months, which research shows can reduce diabetes progression risk significantly.

Monitoring Plan: Repeat HbA1c in 6 months to assess response to lifestyle interventions. If HbA1c remains elevated or increases despite lifestyle changes, will discuss metformin for diabetes prevention.

Patient Education: Explained that prediabetes is reversible with lifestyle changes, unlike diabetes. Discussed diabetes complications to increase motivation. Patient verbalized understanding and expressed strong commitment to prevention efforts.

Follow-up: Return in 3 months to discuss DPP progress and provide additional support. Phone call in 2 weeks to ensure successful enrollment in prevention program.

---

Example 2: Prediabetes Not Responding to Lifestyle Changes

Patient: 55-year-old male
Chief Complaint: Follow-up prediabetes, repeat labs review
Visit: Chronic disease management

S – Subjective:

Patient returns for prediabetes follow-up, 8 months after initial diagnosis. Has been working on lifestyle modifications with mixed success. Lost 8 lbs initially but regained 4 lbs over past 2 months. Reports difficulty maintaining dietary changes due to work travel schedule and stress eating. Walks 3-4 days weekly for 30 minutes but inconsistent with routine. Attended 6 sessions of diabetes prevention program but dropped out citing scheduling conflicts with work. Denies symptoms of hyperglycemia. Concerned about progression to diabetes, especially after brother recently diagnosed with type 2 diabetes at age 52.

O – Objective:

Vital Signs: BP 132/84, HR 78, Wt 198 lbs (down 4 lbs from initial visit 8 months ago, but up 4 lbs from 3-month low)
BMI: 28.7 (down from 29.4 initially)
Labs (fasting, drawn 3 days ago):

• HbA1c: 6.3% (increased from 6.0% at diagnosis)
• Fasting glucose: 118 mg/dL (increased from 108 mg/dL)
• Lipid panel: Stable on current statin
• Creatinine: 1.0 mg/dL Previous labs for comparison:
• 8 months ago: HbA1c 6.0%, FBG 108 mg/dL
• Today: HbA1c 6.3%, FBG 118 mg/dL (worsening trend)

A – Assessment:

Prediabetes, progressing despite attempted lifestyle interventions. HbA1c increased from 6.0% to 6.3% over 8 months, indicating inadequate glycemic control and high risk for progression to type 2 diabetes. Patient has struggled with sustained lifestyle modification despite initial efforts and incomplete DPP participation. Risk factors include: age >45, overweight (BMI 28.7), first-degree relative with diabetes, progressive worsening of glycemic markers. Estimated >80% probability of developing type 2 diabetes within 5 years without more intensive intervention. Patient now meets criteria for pharmacologic intervention for diabetes prevention per ADA guidelines (prediabetes + additional risk factors + failed lifestyle modification).

P – Plan:

Pharmacologic Intervention: Discussed metformin for diabetes prevention given progression of prediabetes despite lifestyle efforts. Research (Diabetes Prevention Program study) shows metformin reduces diabetes risk by 31% in high-risk individuals. Initiated metformin 500mg once daily with dinner, will titrate to 850mg twice daily over 4 weeks if tolerated. Reviewed common side effects including GI upset and how to minimize by taking with food and gradual titration. Ordered baseline vitamin B12 level (metformin can cause B12 deficiency with long-term use).

Renewed Lifestyle Emphasis: While starting medication, emphasized that lifestyle modification remains critical and metformin is adjunctive, not replacement. Discussed realistic strategies for dietary adherence during travel: choosing protein-focused meals, avoiding sugary beverages, portion awareness. Recommended meal planning on weekends for upcoming week.

Structured Support: Re-referred to diabetes prevention program with emphasis on virtual/online options that may work better with work schedule. Some insurance plans cover digital DPP platforms with flexible scheduling.

Enhanced Monitoring: Repeat HbA1c in 4 months (earlier than standard 6-month interval given progression trend). Will consider endocrinology referral if continues to progress despite metformin and lifestyle efforts.

Follow-up: Return in 6 weeks to assess metformin tolerance and review B12 level. Then every 3 months for prediabetes monitoring with HbA1c trending.

---

Example 3: Prediabetes in Pregnancy History (High Risk)

Patient: 34-year-old female
Chief Complaint: Postpartum follow-up, discussing blood sugar screening
Visit: Postpartum care

S – Subjective:

Patient presents for 12-week postpartum visit following pregnancy complicated by gestational diabetes mellitus (GDM). Was on insulin during pregnancy, discontinued after delivery. Did not follow up for recommended glucose screening at 6-12 weeks postpartum as advised. Reports feeling well, no concerning symptoms. Currently breastfeeding. No polyuria, polydipsia, or unusual fatigue. Busy with newborn care, diet has been erratic and exercise minimal. Has not checked any blood sugars since delivery. Family history includes mother with type 2 diabetes. Pre-pregnancy weight 165 lbs, current weight 172 lbs (retained 15 lbs from pregnancy).

O – Objective:

Vital Signs: BP 118/72, HR 74, Wt 172 lbs, BMI 27.8
General: Well-appearing, appropriate for postpartum period
Labs (fasting, drawn today):

• HbA1c: 5.9% (prediabetes range)
• Fasting glucose: 104 mg/dL (prediabetes range)
• 2-hour oral glucose tolerance test (performed in office): 155 mg/dL (prediabetes defined as 140-199 mg/dL) Note: Patient meets prediabetes criteria on both HbA1c and OGTT

A – Assessment:

Prediabetes in patient with history of gestational diabetes mellitus. This places patient at extremely high risk for type 2 diabetes—women with previous GDM have 7-fold increased risk of developing type 2 diabetes compared to those without GDM history. Current prediabetes represents partial resolution of pregnancy-related glucose intolerance but incomplete return to normal glucose metabolism. Additional risk factors include: overweight (BMI 27.8), postpartum weight retention, family history of diabetes. Requires aggressive preventive intervention given very high-risk status. Also documented: history of gestational diabetes mellitus (ICD-10: O24.419 for history in subsequent encounter).

P – Plan:

High-Risk Prevention Strategy: Explained that having gestational diabetes increases lifetime diabetes risk significantly, and current prediabetes numbers confirm ongoing risk. Emphasized critical importance of prevention efforts to protect long-term health and ability to care for family.

Diabetes Prevention Program: Enrolled in diabetes prevention program with postpartum-specific cohort if available (some programs offer mother-baby exercise classes and support for breastfeeding women). Program tailored for postpartum women addresses barriers like childcare and breastfeeding nutrition needs.

Weight Loss Target: Goal to return to pre-pregnancy weight (165 lbs) and then achieve 5-7% weight loss from that baseline. Discussed safe weight loss strategies while breastfeeding: focus on nutrient-dense foods, avoid very low-calorie diets, gradual 1-2 lb weekly loss.

Future Pregnancy Planning: Discussed importance of achieving optimal glucose control before any future pregnancies. If planning another pregnancy, recommend preconception counseling to optimize metabolic health and reduce GDM recurrence risk.

Intensive Monitoring: Given high-risk status, will check HbA1c every 3-4 months (more frequent than typical 6-month interval for lower-risk prediabetes). Annual screening recommended lifelong due to GDM history even if glucose normalizes.

Contraception Discussion: Reviewed contraceptive options, recommended avoiding methods that may worsen insulin resistance (certain progestin-only methods) if possible.

Follow-up: Return in 3 months for HbA1c recheck and DPP progress review. Will consider metformin if no improvement with lifestyle efforts given very high-risk profile. Patient educated on symptoms requiring urgent evaluation. Provided written information on diabetes risk after gestational diabetes and prevention strategies.

---

Essential Documentation Elements for Prediabetes Notes

After reviewing thousands of prediabetes notes and insurance denials, here's what you must include:

Specific Diagnostic Values

Never write "borderline diabetes" or "slightly elevated glucose." Always document actual HbA1c percentage and/or fasting glucose value with the diagnostic range in parentheses.

Example: "HbA1c 6.2% (prediabetes range 5.7-6.4%)" or "Fasting glucose 114 mg/dL (prediabetes range 100-125 mg/dL)"

ICD-10 Code R73.03

Document "prediabetes" explicitly in your assessment. Some systems automatically generate the code, others require you to write it. Either way, this specific diagnosis code is required for DPP coverage and many preventive services.

BMI Documentation

For diabetes prevention program referrals, document actual BMI. Programs require BMI ≥25 (or ≥23 for Asian Americans). Insurance won't approve DPP referrals without documented BMI meeting criteria.

Risk Stratification

Document additional diabetes risk factors beyond just the prediabetes numbers: family history, ethnicity (higher risk in African American, Hispanic, Native American, Asian American, Pacific Islander populations), history of gestational diabetes, PCOS, previous higher glucose readings, age >45, overweight/obesity, sedentary lifestyle.

Previous Values for Trending

When available, compare current HbA1c to previous values. Documentation like "HbA1c 6.4%, increased from 6.0% six months ago" demonstrates progression that justifies more intensive intervention.

Lifestyle Modification Documentation

Even if brief, document that you discussed diet, physical activity, and weight loss. This is required for quality measures and creates the foundation for escalating to medication if lifestyle efforts fail.

Prevention Program Eligibility

When referring to DPP or medical nutrition therapy, explicitly document that the patient meets eligibility criteria: prediabetes diagnosis (with specific values), BMI ≥25, and no previous type 1 or type 2 diabetes diagnosis.

Common Prediabetes Documentation Mistakes

I've analyzed hundreds of denied insurance claims for diabetes prevention services. These documentation errors come up repeatedly:

Using vague terminology: "Borderline diabetes," "pre-diabetic," or "glucose intolerance" instead of the specific diagnosis "prediabetes" with ICD-10 code R73.03.

Missing actual lab values: Writing "HbA1c elevated" without the specific percentage makes the note useless for insurance review and DPP referrals.

No BMI documentation: DPP programs can't process referrals without documented BMI meeting their criteria (≥25 or ≥23 for Asian Americans).

Failing to document lifestyle counseling: When you later want to justify metformin or other interventions, you need documentation showing lifestyle modification was attempted first.

Not establishing medical necessity: Simply having prediabetes isn't always sufficient for insurance to cover intensive services. Document risk factors and potential complications to establish why prevention efforts are medically necessary.

Missing comparison to previous values: Progression from 5.9% to 6.3% tells a different story than stable 5.9% for two years. Trending matters for treatment decisions.

Special Populations Requiring Enhanced Documentation

Certain prediabetes patients need extra documentation detail because their risk profile or insurance requirements differ:

Women with gestational diabetes history: Always document the GDM history (even years later) because it qualifies them for more frequent screening and sometimes enhanced insurance coverage for prevention programs. Use ICD-10 code for GDM history: O24.419.

Patients on medications that increase diabetes risk: If someone is taking atypical antipsychotics, steroids, or other medications known to affect glucose metabolism, document this as a contributing factor that increases urgency of prevention efforts.

Patients with PCOS: Women with polycystic ovary syndrome have insulin resistance as a core feature. Document PCOS diagnosis alongside prediabetes as it affects treatment approach and sometimes insurance coverage for metformin.

High-risk ethnic populations: While you should document ethnicity routinely, it's particularly important for prediabetes notes because Asian Americans qualify for DPP at lower BMI thresholds (≥23 vs ≥25).

What Happens When Documentation Is Done Right

Proper prediabetes documentation unlocks resources that can genuinely prevent diabetes:

Your patient gets enrolled in a free or low-cost diabetes prevention program that provides a year of weekly coaching, accountability, and structured lifestyle intervention proven to reduce diabetes risk by 58%.

Insurance covers medical nutrition therapy visits with a registered dietitian who provides personalized meal planning and strategies tailored to your patient's life.

If lifestyle interventions fail despite good efforts, you have documented evidence supporting metformin for prevention, which insurance is more likely to cover when the paper trail shows appropriate progressive intervention.

Most importantly, you've created documentation protecting you legally if the patient later develops diabetes—you can demonstrate that prediabetes was identified early, patient was counseled appropriately, and prevention resources were offered.

How SOAP Notes Doctor Handles Prediabetes Documentation

When you document prediabetes visits using SOAP Notes Doctor, the system automatically:

• Includes specific HbA1c and/or fasting glucose values prominently
• Incorporates proper ICD-10 coding (R73.03 for prediabetes)
• Documents BMI for DPP eligibility
• Creates risk stratification language using patient's specific factors
• Includes diabetes prevention program eligibility documentation
• Compares to previous values when you provide them
• Incorporates lifestyle counseling documentation
• Uses insurance-friendly language for medical necessity

You provide the clinical details—lab values, patient history, what you discussed.

The system formats everything to meet insurance requirements for prevention program coverage, quality measure reporting, and medical necessity documentation.

Try it at soapnotes.doctor and see how it simplifies prediabetes documentation while improving prevention program access for your patients.

Final Thoughts

Prediabetes documentation has higher stakes than most providers realize.

You're not just recording lab values—you're opening or closing doors to prevention resources that could fundamentally alter your patient's health trajectory.

The difference between "glucose slightly elevated" and "prediabetes (HbA1c 6.1%, BMI 29.5)" is the difference between insurance denying or approving a year-long prevention program worth thousands of dollars.

Get the documentation right, and you give your patients fighting chance to avoid diabetes entirely.

Your notes should work as hard for prevention as you do.

---

Ready to document prediabetes effectively?
Visit soapnotes.doctor and create prevention-focused notes in minutes.